After Marriage Equality, have donors forgotten about LGBT charities?
Written with Rachel Stephenson Sheff
Whilst celebrating 49 years of Pride this June, and our extraordinary progress in recent years, it’s important to acknowledge the critical role our community has always played in nurturing and protecting the next generation of LGBT people. And as we continue to feel the effects of our lost generation of leaders — taken from us by AIDS and violence — we have some big shoes to fill when it comes to investing in our collective future.
Unfortunately, in our philanthropy advisory team we’re seeing shifts in LGBT charitable giving that have us worried: since the UK’s 2013 Equal Marriage Act there has been an alarming drop in donations of every size to LGBT causes, and we have not seen any funding shift from marriage campaigns to other vital needs within the community — it’s simply disappeared.
To paint the picture: in the last year, UNISON found charities serving the LGBT community are less popular with formal funders and more reliant on the public for funding, [1] yet according to the LGBT Consortium, only 11% of income for UK LGBT organisations now comes from individual donations (compared to a charity sector average of 45.2%).[2] In the last year alone, 32% of LGBT groups saw a decrease in funding, and nearly 50% reported they had to lose staff because of this.[3]
Despite our incredible victories — including equal marriage, parenting rights and PrEP — there are still urgent problems faced by our queer siblings that need and deserve our attention. LGBT hate crime in the UK has surged by almost 80% over last four years[4]; our social and community spaces often exclude people of colour; trans people face danger, stigmatisation and medical gatekeeping at every turn; and we have some of the highest rates of mental illness among any group.[5] That’s before you even consider the quarter of all homeless youth who identify as LGBT[6], and the loneliness epidemic faced by elderly LGBT people excluded from mainstream services.[7]
But there’s good news. Despite this challenging climate, brilliant organisations working on these issues still exist, and still have the potential to protect and drive forward our place in society. From small charities like Mermaids (working with trans kids and their parents) and NAZ Project (providing sexual health services to LGBT people of colour), to big well-known organisations like Albert Kennedy Trust (supporting LGBT homeless young people) and Stonewall (advocating for LGBT rights across the country) — there are so many opportunities to invest in our community and an incredible variety of approaches to choose from. Even if you can’t make up your mind, you can always support the LGBT Consortium, which works to strengthen the LGBT charity sector as a whole.
“As a philanthropist, I have the opportunity to leverage my giving to improve the difficult and even life-threatening conditions facing so many who are just like me and my partner.” — Sascha McGregor, UK LGBTI Donor Initiative (Philanthropy Impact, 2016)
So in this important month of Pride, when we have much to celebrate, we must also remember the origin of Pride, which began as a protest — not a parade — in resistance to the oppression of queer people. While much has changed since then, it is still a privilege to be proud. And it is not a privilege afforded to all members of our community. LGBT philanthropists, whether they have £10 per month or millions to give, have a brilliant opportunity to change this. So, this Pride, we are challenging and inviting our queer community to step up alongside us to protect our collective future. If not us, then who?
Sources
[1] UNISON, Implications of reductions to public spending for LGB and T people and services, November 2016
[2] LGBT Consortium, A Snap Shot of the LGBT Sector, August 2016 (no longer available)
[3] LGBT Consortium, The LGBT Fund, April 2018
[4] The Independent, Attacks on LGBT people surge almost 80% in UK over last four years, September 2017
[5] Mental Health Foundation, Mental health statistics: LGBT people, 2018
[6] The FT, Down and out: why so many homeless youths are LGBT, May 2017
[7] Age UK, Combating loneliness amongst older LGBT people, February 2018
While philanthropy and football may seem worlds apart, I’ve started thinking about the many similarities that can provide valuable lessons for those in the philanthropic sector. I for one, am always learning about the essential elements of football that can inspire and inform effective philanthropy.
Through the power of collective design, our fundraiser and grantmaker #FixTheFlow Fellows have imagined the future of our philanthropic funding system, and we should all listen carefully.
In the coming months, our Associate Carli is exploring the complexities of social innovation and will share her learnings, insights, and questions with you.
I.G.’s CEO Emily shares some of the mistakes and challenges she found during her leadership journey, and what she learned and will share in I.G.’s new Leadership Lab.
I’m expected to show up as a leader, but don’t feel like a leader. Introducing Impact & Grow: A Leadership Lab.
Leveraging Limited Funds For Humanitarians: Insights from the 2024 #HX24 conference, organised by Save the Children UK and the Humanitarian Leadership Academy.
Social enterprises have a particularly interesting relationship with Monitoring, Evaluation and Learning (MEL) as they need to capture both the financial and social/ environmental impact of their work, and speak to a wide range of potential funders and investors. Caitlin McLoughlin chatted to Abhinav Khanal, Co-Founder and Executive Director of Bean Voyage, to explore this further.
Image Credit: Bean Voyage
A round up of everything the I.G. team did in 2023!
Introducing a new, dedicated funders stream to I.G.’s #FixTheFlow Fellowship! We’re accepting applications until 17th November (for a 2024 start). Join our movement at fixtheflow.org
Join us for one (or all!) our eight workshops in our Autumn Training Series, where we will cover some of the trickiest topics facing fundraisers today.
What does meaningful and effective learning actually mean in practice?
Our Advisor Caitlin interviews Kore Global’s Emily Boost on learning how to learn and all things feminist evaluation and learning.
How do we balance our passion and our desire to give our best, whilst not being consumed by failure to live up to our own or others’ expectations?
At I.G. Advisors (I.G.), we’re often approached to design and implement evaluations for our clients to understand the impact of their grantmaking, fundraising or programmatic strategies, and identify opportunities for evolution.
The ‘lone saviour’ approach won’t cut it (and it also might destroy you).
It’s hard to believe it now that we’re living through a polycrisis, but the financial crisis and Great Recession of the 00s felt like a once-in-a-lifetime jolt to the world order at the time.
What you can learn from others leading philanthropic networks like yours
‘Well, we could have called that one.’
I.G. Advisors (I.G.) recently had the pleasure of collaborating with The Big Give and Rosa on the Women and Girls Match Fund.
Being a parent is often a thankless task. You take something and nurture it, treating it with love and care, losing sleep and worrying if — against all odds — , it will achieve its full potential and become the best it can be. It may never, ever show gratitude for your sacrifice. And then one day it will grow up and leave.
New I.G. Insights report explores how fundraisers and funders can support digital fundraising for racial justice issues.
#TaxPhilanthropy — wealth holders have the power to pay more tax right now even if governments fail to reform their policies
How starting small might be the most effective way to change the world.
An insight into “Modern Grantmaking: A Guide for Funders Who Believe Better is Possible”
A couple of weeks ago, I.G. brought back its much-loved book club event for our first in-person get together in over a year.
Podcast listeners — a new episode of What Donors Want is out! We had the honour of speaking with David Simas, CEO of the Obama Foundation.
(Spoiler: our 2020 Small Business Award does)
This past year has been unlike any that we’ve ever experienced before. There have been significant changes, opportunities, and challenges in the ways we use technology, interact in communities, and approach giving and philanthropy — all of which have spurred much-needed transformation (and hope!) during a time when nothing seemed possible.
Podcast listeners — a new episode of What Donors Want is out! We had the pleasure of diving into participatory grant-making (PGM) with Hannah Paterson, Senior Portfolio Manager at The National Lottery Community Fund.